Build Your 4-Pack

(23 customer reviews)



  Product Quantity
Roasted Red Pepper Hummus
Fresh Lemon Garlic Hummus
Fresh Lemon Beet Hummus
Fresh Lemon Dill Hummus
Smoked Chipotle Hummus
Classic Hummus


23 reviews for Build Your 4-Pack

  1. Robin M

    Best hummus I’ve ever had…Tried a sample at Wegmans when local companies were adversing their products and ended up buying the smoked chipotle because I tend to like spicy…The flavor is unbelievable…I checked online to see where I could purchase the hummus and was thrilled to find out that Wegmans is carrying it. Cannot wait to try all the other flavors

    • ithacacoldcrafted (verified owner)

      Robin, thanks for writing in and sharing the kind words about our hummus! Enjoy!

  2. Jenny

    Hands down the best & freshest hummus I’ve ever tasted. Honestly, it’s not even fair to other hummus brands how good this stuff is.

    • ithacacoldcrafted (verified owner)

      Thanks for the review Jenny! We’re glad you enjoy our hummus. Subscribe to our newsletter if you’d like to stay up to date with exciting news, delicious recipes, and exclusive specials!

  3. Indy

    I am not one to write reviews but this is hands down the best hummus I’ve ever had. A friend brought the lemon garlic flavor to a get together earlier and I had to restrain myself from eating it all. I woke up thinking about this hummus and am excited to find out they sell it at a store up the block from me. They open at 10am and I and plan on trying every flavor they have in stock.

    • ithacacoldcrafted (verified owner)

      Thank you so much for the kind review! We’re thrilled you love our hummus. That’s a good friend for restraining you, but it’s probably because they wanted it too. 🙂

  4. Danielle

    This is the best god damn hummus I’ve ever had. I love love love the Lemon Garlic. I am moving to Florida soon and fully intend to order bundles online to ensure I continue to get my fix. Keep doin’ what you’re doin’.

    • ithacacoldcrafted (verified owner)

      Danielle thanks for the message! We’re glad our online store will help you get your hummus fix! Subscribe to our newsletter to stay up to date with exciting news and recipes! Maybe some good coupons too 🙂

  5. Christine

    The Ithaca Cold-Crafted Lemon Beet is out of this world. (Yeah, they’re all excellent. But this is my FAVE!) Now pairing it with Rose wines and Rose ciders at home. YUM.

    • ithacacoldcrafted (verified owner)

      We love the wining pairing ideas! Let us know what works best for you. Turn up the Beet!

  6. Elyse

    Absolutely the best hummus on the market! The beet hummus is my FAVORITE! So much flavor and so versatile. I love adding the smokey chipotle to wraps or quesadillas and I top my avocado toast every morning now with a layer of the beet hummus. Great job! So glad I found this at The Fresh Market!

    • ithacacoldcrafted (verified owner)

      Elyse, we’re glad you found us at Fresh Market too! Take some pics of your food with our product and share them with us on Instagram. We’d love to see some of your recipes!

  7. Camryn

    This is the first review I’ve written for anything but this is literally the best hummus I’ve ever tried (and I’ve tried a lot). It is delicious! I got the lemon garlic flavor at a Whole Foods on the Upper East Side in New York, and I am SO sad because I’m from Arizona and only living in New York temporarily so I won’t be able to get it when I go home. Please bring this hummus to AZ!!!

    • ithacacoldcrafted (verified owner)

      Camryn, that’s why we have the online store–for fans like you! You can definitely have it shipped to Arizona and it will be just as fresh as picking it up from the grocery store. Sign up for our newsletter to stay up to date with exciting news and offers!

  8. Jan

    I hate you guys because I can sit there and eat this stuff with a spoon and finish the whole darn container. Best. Hummus. Ever.

    • ithacacoldcrafted (verified owner)

      It’s a real problem! Thanks Jan!

  9. Alexa Rink

    I was doing a demo at the Harrisburg PA,Wegmans for a regional kombucha and noticed Ithaca Hummus on the shelf. I was initially attracted to the clean packaging and wanted to support a local company, so I purchased the Dill Lemon flavor. I was/still am BLOWN AWAY by the outstanding quality of Ithaca Hummus. I purchase it every time I go to Wegmans, whether I need it or not.
    More people need to know about how great your Hummus is. I would love to demo Ithaca Hummus, if that was ever possible, because it’s always so much better to promote a brand when you truly love their product! Thank you for making such and exquisite hummus!

    • ithacacoldcrafted (verified owner)

      Alex, thanks for the praise! If you’re interested in doing a demo email [email protected]. Thanks for reaching out!

  10. Lindsey Miller

    Tried a sample at Bonterra’s Organic Market in S. Jersey, thought “Wow, this is really good!” kept shopping, came back for SECONDS, then grabbed 2 flavors to take home. I’ve been munching on it with the Late July Sea Salt tortilla chips – sooo good! Will definitely be ordering online for convenience!

    • ithacacoldcrafted (verified owner)

      Thanks for the love, Lindsey! So happy you enjoyed our hummus. Keep coming back for seconds and feel free to order our hummus straight to your doorstep in our online shop.

  11. Craig Fleishman

    Best packaged hummus, ever.

    • ithacacoldcrafted (verified owner)

      Thanks Craig!

  12. Stephanie

    Best hummus I’ve had in a very long time – reminds me of the best fresh hummus from Dearborn, MI, where I’m from. Bought mine at Sendik’s in Franklin, WI. Please keep selling to them!

    • ithacacoldcrafted (verified owner)

      Thanks for the message Stephanie! We’re glad you’re a fan of our hummus!

  13. Jim B.

    Mortified to learn that the Fresh Market store two miles from my house is closing. Fresh Market is the only source in the western suburbs of Chicago for Ithaca Hummus. Nearest place now is 20 miles away. Easily the best hummus that I have had . . . both prepared or in a restaurant. I implore you to knock on Whole Foods door and start selling there. No direct access to Ithaca Hummus will significantly degrade my quality of life!

    • ithacacoldcrafted (verified owner)

      Jim, have you checked out location map to see if there’s another location nearby that may have our hummus? We hope there is! Otherwise, you can always order 4 packs online!

  14. Jill

    I tried this while in New York and absolutely loved it! Problem is I live in South Florida and can’t find it. Want to order the four pack but want to know the shelf life and can you freeze it?

    • ithacacoldcrafted (verified owner)

      Jill, check out our blog on . It explains how our cold press process extends the shelf life. For the freshest flavor we recommend finishing our hummus within 7 days AFTER opening it. However, unopened hummus has a shelf life of 100 days. We wouldn’t recommend freezing it.

  15. JoAnn

    I am so in love with roasted red pepper hummus I am becoming addicted just the right lemon zest and red pepper combo so fresh tastes like homemade
    Here on Long Island I have no problem finding your products I am relocating to Northern New Jersey and hope to find it there as well if not I have no problem taking a drive back to LongIsland to get my fix I cant wait to try your other products

    • ithacacoldcrafted (verified owner)

      Thanks for the message JoAnn! When you move to Northern New Jersey you can always use our Location finder on the website to see where you can pick up our hummus!

  16. Erin Palma

    Don’t tell my husband, I am leaving him for the hummus, seriously I’m in love!

    • ithacacoldcrafted (verified owner)

      LOL! Erin, this is incredible. Your secret is safe with us…and the rest of the internet 🙂

  17. Lisa

    We eat a LOT of hummus and have tried many brands, but this is by far the absolute best hummus we’ve ever had. The Lemon Dill is amazing!!! Even my husband loves it and he’s not a hummus fan. Thank you for this remarkable product!!

    • ithacacoldcrafted (verified owner)

      Lisa, thanks for the review! This hummus is the REAL DILL 🙂 We’re glad you enjoy it.

  18. Patrick Brown

    I used to like hummus. Since I’ve been eating Ithaca Hummas, I love it. It doesn’t have that paste feeling on my tongue. But a fresh soft smooth taste. OK, I like Lemon and Beet the most.

    • ithacacoldcrafted (verified owner)

      Thanks for the message Patrick! We’re glad Ithaca Cold-Crafted hummus has turned you in to a fanatic!

  19. Ilana


    • ithacacoldcrafted (verified owner)

      Speaking the truth! Thanks Ilana!

  20. Khadijah

    HANDS DOWN! You are the WINNER!
    Agree with everyone above! I already
    like Hummus a lot!! I tried the beet one
    first, about to try the others ASAP. I was a litte blown awayyyyy!! Great job, clean, flavorful, no sugar. That lemon and the cold, etc…your ratios are down pat! Nailed it. Just looking for the coupons now😊. Thanks 🙏🏾

    • ithacacoldcrafted (verified owner)

      Denise, thanks for leaving a review! Spoken like a hummus pro. We’re glad that we can be your first choice!

  21. Amanda

    I eat hummus most days with my lunch or as a snack at work and have tried so many brands, even occasionally make my own. This is the best I ever had. I’m so glad my Publix carries it! All of the flavors are great, not sure I can pick a favorite:)

    • ithacacoldcrafted (verified owner)

      Amanda, thanks for the review! We’re super excited to be in Publix now too!

  22. Jay

    Best hummus I ever tasted! I saw that customers kept buying it and reccomended it, so I decided to give it a try. Best decision I ever made, it is soooo good. Best hummus out there hands down, I will keep buying!

    • ithacacoldcrafted (verified owner)

      Jay, we love the feedback! Thank you! Sign up for our newsletter by visiting our website so you can stay up to date with all things Ithaca Cold-Crafted hummus!

  23. Bonnie

    Undoubtedly the best hummus I have ever had in my entire life. The beet lemon hummus is unreal. Such fresh lemon flavor, tangy and satisfying!! No other hummus can compare. You guys seriously figured it out, please don’t ever change!!

    • ithacacoldcrafted (verified owner)

      Bonnie, what great compliments! Thank you so much for the kind words. Did you know you can save $1 OFF on your next purchase by visiting ?

Add a review

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *